In every edition of MLB The Show, fans eagerly mlb the show 25 stubsawait the ratings reveal. It’s more than just numbers—it’s a reflection of real-life dominance, player popularity, and how gamers will approach roster building. MLB The Show 25 is no different, and its top 10 player ratings offer a compelling mix of legends in the making and superstars at their peak. Let’s break down the elite ten.

1. Shohei Ohtani (99 OVR – Dodgers)
Ohtani remains a unicorn, and even though he's not pitching in 2025, his bat alone is worthy of a 99. He hits for average and power, steals bases, and can anchor any lineup. His unique DH-only role in The Show is a slight limitation, but it hardly detracts from his game-breaking impact.

2. Aaron Judge (99 OVR – Yankees)
Judge’s massive frame and home run power make him a dream slugger in both real life and The Show. His arm strength in right field and plate discipline also bump his fielding and vision ratings, making him more than just a long-ball threat.

3. Juan Soto (99 OVR – Mets)
Now the proud owner of the biggest contract in sports history, Soto’s smooth swing, high OBP, and elite contact/power split make him one of the most reliable hitters in the game. His lefty bat fits perfectly in most lineups, and his plate vision gives him a wide PCI, even in high difficulties.

4. Ronald Acuña Jr. (98 OVR – Braves)
Acuña’s MVP-caliber 2024 season solidified his status as a five-tool monster. In The Show, his speed, power, and arm strength make him a triple threat in the outfield. He’s also a steal machine, meaning he can wreck games on the bases.

5. Mookie Betts (97 OVR – Dodgers)
Whether it’s his Gold Glove defense, timely hitting, or clutch leadership, Mookie is a cornerstone player. In The Show, his positional flexibility is a huge plus—he can play 2B, RF, or CF effectively, giving users lineup freedom.

6. Freddie Freeman (96 OVR – Dodgers)
Freeman continues to rake, and The Show reflects his offensive consistency with high contact and clutch stats. His defense at first base and ability to hit to all fields makes him a must-have for players who value smart, situational baseball.

7. Corbin Burnes (96 OVR – Orioles)
One of the best right-handed starters in the game, Burnes boasts elite control, break, and a devastating cutter. In The Show, he’s a go-to ace in Franchise mode or online rotation.

8. Ketel Marte (96 OVR – Diamondbacks)
Often underrated, Marte is finally getting his due. With above-average power, contact, and speed, he’s one of the most versatile second basemen in the game. His switch-hitting also makes him matchup-proof.

9. Francisco Lindor (95 OVR – Mets)
Lindor’s combination of elite defense, base-running intelligence, and switch-hitting ability make him one of the most well-rounded shortstops. He’s a spark plug both in real life and in Diamond Dynasty.

10. Gerrit Cole (95 OVR – Yankees)
Still a dominant force on the mound, Cole’s high strikeout rate and ability to handle big innings make him the Yankees’ anchor and a rotation must-have for players seeking a power pitcher who also limits walks.

Together, these ten players set the bar in MLB The Show 25. Whether you're building a dynasty or competing online, these names will be on every gamer’s radar.